[Bug 1872983] Re: in netcat-openbsd manpage, port argument description is not good

[Heinrich Schuchardt]

This package is copied from Debian. Please, open send a bug report
there. Cf. https://www.debian.org/Bugs/Reporting.

** Changed in: netcat-openbsd (Ubuntu)
       Status: New => Confirmed

-- 
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu
Foundations Bugs, which is subscribed to netcat-openbsd in Ubuntu.
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1872983

Title:
  in netcat-openbsd manpage, port argument description is not good

Status in netcat-openbsd package in Ubuntu:
  Confirmed

Bug description:
  in netcat-openbsd manpage, port argument description is not good. it
  is this:

  "port can be a specified as a numeric port number, or as a service
  name.  Ports may be specified in a range of the form nn-mm.  In
  general, a destination port must be specified, unless the -U option is
  given."

  why this is not good:

  really, the port argument also is used as source port: while using "nc
  -l 1234". this "nc -l 1234" is an example from the manpage in
  "CLIENT/SERVER MODEL" section, which is immediately after the port
  argument description. and this command works correctly. (while
  connecting from other computer with nc IPaddressHere 1234, it works,
  and in that case i think it is destination port, and thus source port
  for the command on first laptop. it must be source port on first comp,
  because a process must listen on a specific source port, they do not
  usually listen on all ports, as i know from my experience... unless it
  is something like tcpdump, and such programs run with root permission,
  while netcat runs with non-root permission... and it is because
  processes should not access to listening ports of other processes... )

  the text "In general, a destination port must be specified, unless the
  -U option is given." is not good, because it says "must" and says "in
  general", and it is hard to disambiguate this. it can be understood as
  "in general" refers to the all cases except the "unless the -U option
  is given". in that way of understanding, it means that if the -U
  option is not given, it must be source port only. but really it is not
  so. so, "in general" does not refer to the all cases except the
  "unless the -U option is given". it just means, that destination port
  is more usually used in this place. but this way of understanding is
  also hard to accept, because the usage, the intention of the extra
  word "must" becomes not understood. it is extra, because it can be
  said shorter: "a destination port is specified", or it can be said
  with less of the fierce: "a destination port should be specified".

To manage notifications about this bug go to:
https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/netcat-openbsd/+bug/1872983/+subscriptions