[Bug 2111817] [NEW] coreutils-from is in main but coreutils-from-uutils is not

[Jeremy Bícha]

Public bug reported:

Currently in questing-proposed,

coreutils has Pre-Depends: coreutils-from-uutils | coreutils-from-gnu

coreutils is in main
coreutils-from-gnu is in main
coreutils-from-uutils is in universe

It looks like britney would allow this to migrate to questing.

I'm filing a blocker bug because the first alternative for a package in
main ought to be in main. In practice, I think this would result in the
universe Ubuntu Desktop Flavor ISOs to pull in coreutils-from-uutils but
the Ubuntu Desktop and Ubuntu Server ISOs to use coreutils-from-gnu. I'm
guessing people upgrading from plucky would also get coreutils-from-
uttils. This is chaotic.

I think that we need to get coreutils-from-uutils and rust-coreutils
into main before allowing this swap to continue. In other words, this is
blocked by LP: #2111815

Other Info
----------
I think this could be said to be a violation of Debian Policy § 2.2.1 once translated to Ubuntu archive specifics.

https://www.debian.org/doc/debian-policy/ch-archive.html#the-main-
archive-area

** Affects: coreutils-from (Ubuntu)
     Importance: High
         Status: Triaged


** Tags: block-proposed questing

** Description changed:

  Currently in questing-proposed,
  
  coreutils has Pre-Depends: coreutils-from-uutils | coreutils-from-gnu
- 
  
  coreutils is in main
  coreutils-from-gnu is in main
  coreutils-from-uutils is in universe
  
  It looks like britney would allow this to migrate to questing.
  
  I'm filing a blocker bug because the first alternative for a package in
  main ought to be in main. In practice, I think this would result in the
  universe Ubuntu Desktop Flavor ISOs to pull in coreutils-from-uutils but
  the Ubuntu Desktop and Ubuntu Server ISOs to use coreutils-from-gnu. I'm
  guessing people upgrading from plucky would also get coreutils-from-
  uttils. This is chaotic.
  
  I think that we need to get coreutils-from-uutils and rust-coreutils
  into main before allowing this swap to continue. In other words, this is
  blocked by LP: #2111815
+ 
+ Other Info
+ ----------
+ I think this could be said to be a violation of Debian Policy § 2.2.1 once translated to Ubuntu archive specifics.
+ 
+ https://www.debian.org/doc/debian-policy/ch-archive.html#the-main-
+ archive-area

-- 
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu
Foundations Bugs, which is subscribed to coreutils-from in Ubuntu.
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/2111817

Title:
  coreutils-from is in main but coreutils-from-uutils is not

Status in coreutils-from package in Ubuntu:
  Triaged

Bug description:
  Currently in questing-proposed,

  coreutils has Pre-Depends: coreutils-from-uutils | coreutils-from-gnu

  coreutils is in main
  coreutils-from-gnu is in main
  coreutils-from-uutils is in universe

  It looks like britney would allow this to migrate to questing.

  I'm filing a blocker bug because the first alternative for a package
  in main ought to be in main. In practice, I think this would result in
  the universe Ubuntu Desktop Flavor ISOs to pull in coreutils-from-
  uutils but the Ubuntu Desktop and Ubuntu Server ISOs to use coreutils-
  from-gnu. I'm guessing people upgrading from plucky would also get
  coreutils-from-uttils. This is chaotic.

  I think that we need to get coreutils-from-uutils and rust-coreutils
  into main before allowing this swap to continue. In other words, this
  is blocked by LP: #2111815

  Other Info
  ----------
  I think this could be said to be a violation of Debian Policy § 2.2.1 once translated to Ubuntu archive specifics.

  https://www.debian.org/doc/debian-policy/ch-archive.html#the-main-
  archive-area

To manage notifications about this bug go to:
https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/coreutils-from/+bug/2111817/+subscriptions