[Bug 2127780] Re: [SRU] [Ubuntu 25.10 Questing] Errors shown in every text session when piboot is not enabled

[Dave Jones]

** Description changed:

+ [ Impact ]
+ 
+ Users who have opted out of the A/B boot mechanism (by overriding flash-
+ kernel's method to Pi) are presented with an incorrect warning on every
+ login via the motd service.
+ 
+ [ Test Plan ]
+ 
+ For all supported models of Raspberry Pi:
+ 
+ 1. Flash questing (25.10) to a spare SD card
+ 
+ 2. Boot and run through first login
+ 
+ 3. Follow the instructions under
+ https://waldorf.waveform.org.uk/2025/pull-yourself-up-by-your-
+ bootstraps.html#tough-as-old-boots to switch back to the "pi" method in
+ flash-kernel
+ 
+ 4. Reboot and login; observe the (erroneous) warning
+ 
+ 5. Enable the -proposed pocket
+ 
+ 6. sudo apt install -t questing-proposed flash-kernel{,-piboot}
+ 
+ 7. Logout and login
+ 
+ 8. Observe the warning no longer appears
+ 
+ 9. sudo flash-kernel
+ 
+ 10. sudo reboot
+ 
+ 11. Ensure reboot operates correctly
+ 
+ 12. Undo the "method:" override; sudo rm /etc/flash-kernel/db; sudo
+ touch /etc/flash-kernel/db
+ 
+ 13. sudo flash-kernel
+ 
+ 14. sudo reboot
+ 
+ [ Regression potential ]
+ 
+ Messing with flash-kernel always brings the possibility of breaking the
+ boot sequence. In this case the only changes to the code are in the
+ piboot portion, so it is safe to restrict testing to those boards that
+ use this (i.e. Raspberry Pis).
+ 
+ However, testing should be done on at least three different generations
+ of Pi (specifically 3, 4, and 5 which have differing portions of their
+ boot in or out of EEPROM) to ensure that boot still operates
+ successfully after.
+ 
+ The test plan specifically includes a portion running flash-kernel and
+ reboot with the proposed version in both configurations (pi and pi-try)
+ to ensure things still operate correctly (not just the warning message).
+ 
+ [ Original Description ]
+ 
  Ubuntu 25.10 Questing for Raspberry Pi. These errors are shown in every
  text session when piboot is not enabled:
  
  cat: /boot/firmware/current/state: No such file or directory (os error 2)
  piboot is in an invalid or unexpected state:
  Please file an issue: ubuntu-bug flash-kernel
  run-parts: /etc/update-motd.d/90-piboot-try exited with return code 2
  
  "/etc/update-motd.d/90-piboot-try" runs the command "/usr/sbin/piboot-
  try --status" that don't have in account the possibility of having
  piboot disabled so as file "/boot/firmware/current/state" just doesn't
  exists it's mistaken with a piboot invalid/unexpected state.
  
  I suggest a change in command piboot-try or in "/etc/update-
  motd.d/90-piboot-try" to first test if piboot is enabled to continue
  checking.

-- 
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu
Foundations Bugs, which is subscribed to flash-kernel in Ubuntu.
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/2127780

Title:
  [SRU] [Ubuntu 25.10 Questing] Errors shown in every text session when
  piboot is not enabled

Status in flash-kernel package in Ubuntu:
  Confirmed
Status in flash-kernel source package in Questing:
  Triaged

Bug description:
  [ Impact ]

  Users who have opted out of the A/B boot mechanism (by overriding
  flash-kernel's method to Pi) are presented with an incorrect warning
  on every login via the motd service.

  [ Test Plan ]

  For all supported models of Raspberry Pi:

  1. Flash questing (25.10) to a spare SD card

  2. Boot and run through first login

  3. Follow the instructions under
  https://waldorf.waveform.org.uk/2025/pull-yourself-up-by-your-
  bootstraps.html#tough-as-old-boots to switch back to the "pi" method
  in flash-kernel

  4. Reboot and login; observe the (erroneous) warning

  5. Enable the -proposed pocket

  6. sudo apt install -t questing-proposed flash-kernel{,-piboot}

  7. Logout and login

  8. Observe the warning no longer appears

  9. sudo flash-kernel

  10. sudo reboot

  11. Ensure reboot operates correctly

  12. Undo the "method:" override; sudo rm /etc/flash-kernel/db; sudo
  touch /etc/flash-kernel/db

  13. sudo flash-kernel

  14. sudo reboot

  [ Regression potential ]

  Messing with flash-kernel always brings the possibility of breaking
  the boot sequence. In this case the only changes to the code are in
  the piboot portion, so it is safe to restrict testing to those boards
  that use this (i.e. Raspberry Pis).

  However, testing should be done on at least three different
  generations of Pi (specifically 3, 4, and 5 which have differing
  portions of their boot in or out of EEPROM) to ensure that boot still
  operates successfully after.

  The test plan specifically includes a portion running flash-kernel and
  reboot with the proposed version in both configurations (pi and pi-
  try) to ensure things still operate correctly (not just the warning
  message).

  [ Original Description ]

  Ubuntu 25.10 Questing for Raspberry Pi. These errors are shown in
  every text session when piboot is not enabled:

  cat: /boot/firmware/current/state: No such file or directory (os error 2)
  piboot is in an invalid or unexpected state:
  Please file an issue: ubuntu-bug flash-kernel
  run-parts: /etc/update-motd.d/90-piboot-try exited with return code 2

  "/etc/update-motd.d/90-piboot-try" runs the command "/usr/sbin/piboot-
  try --status" that don't have in account the possibility of having
  piboot disabled so as file "/boot/firmware/current/state" just doesn't
  exists it's mistaken with a piboot invalid/unexpected state.

  I suggest a change in command piboot-try or in "/etc/update-
  motd.d/90-piboot-try" to first test if piboot is enabled to continue
  checking.

To manage notifications about this bug go to:
https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/flash-kernel/+bug/2127780/+subscriptions