[Bug 1917288] [NEW] Missing to package ceph-kvstore-tool, ceph-monstore-tool, ceph-osdomap-tool in bionic-train UCA release

[dongdong tao]

Public bug reported:

ceph-kvstore-tool, ceph-monstore-tool, ceph-osdomap-tool were shipped
within ceph-test package,but the ceph-test package was dropped by [0] in
bionic-train UCA release.

I believe the reason is that most of the binaries (except those 3 tools)
in ceph-test package are meant for just testing and developing, they are
not needed for production env, so the idea to drop this package is good,
but those 3 tools were also dropped along with this package.

Those 3 tools are very important to troubleshoot production issues, so
we need to add them back.

Since Luminous, upstream realized that it doesn't make sense to put them
into ceph-test package, so they've moved those 3 tools to different
packages in PR[1].

So, to fix this, we should do the same as upstream, which is :

Move ceph-kvstore-tool  to ceph-base package
Move ceph-monstore-tool to ceph-mon package
Move ceph-osdomap-tool  to ceph-osd package

Worth mentioning that, upstream also added a PR[2] after [1] was landed
to fix an upgrade failure, it claims that [1] didn't update the
relationship between those packages accordingly, thus caused the upgrade
failure

Note that this only affects Train, Ussuri does contain those 3 tools.

[0]https://launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/ceph/14.2.1-0ubuntu1
[1]https://github.com/ceph/ceph/pull/18289
[2]https://github.com/ceph/ceph/pull/18474

** Affects: ceph (Ubuntu)
     Importance: Undecided
         Status: New

** Description changed:

- ceph-kvstore-tool, ceph-monstore-tool, ceph-osdomap-tool were shipped within ceph-test package,
- But the ceph-test package was dropped by [0] in bionic-train UCA release.
+ ceph-kvstore-tool, ceph-monstore-tool, ceph-osdomap-tool were shipped
+ within ceph-test package,but the ceph-test package was dropped by [0] in
+ bionic-train UCA release.
  
- I believe the reason is that most of the binaries (except those 3 tools) in ceph-test package 
- are meant for just testing and developing, they are not needed for production env, so the idea to
- drop this package is good, but those 3 tools were also dropped along with this package.
+ I believe the reason is that most of the binaries (except those 3 tools)
+ in ceph-test package are meant for just testing and developing, they are
+ not needed for production env, so the idea to drop this package is good,
+ but those 3 tools were also dropped along with this package.
  
  Those 3 tools are very important to troubleshoot production issues, so
  we need to add them back.
  
  Since Luminous, upstream realized that it doesn't make sense to put them
  into ceph-test package, so they've moved those 3 tools to different
  packages in PR[1].
  
  So, to fix this, we should do the same as upstream, which is :
  
  Move ceph-kvstore-tool  to ceph-base package
  Move ceph-monstore-tool to ceph-mon package
  Move ceph-osdomap-tool  to ceph-osd package
  
- Worth mentioning that, upstream also added a PR[2] after [1] was landed to fix an upgrade 
- failure, it claims that [1] didn't update the relationship between those packages accordingly, thus
- caused the upgrade failure
+ Worth mentioning that, upstream also added a PR[2] after [1] was landed
+ to fix an upgrade failure, it claims that [1] didn't update the
+ relationship between those packages accordingly, thus caused the upgrade
+ failure
  
  Note that this only affects Train, Ussuri does contain those 3 tools.
  
  [0]https://launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/ceph/14.2.1-0ubuntu1
  [1]https://github.com/ceph/ceph/pull/18289
  [2]https://github.com/ceph/ceph/pull/18474

-- 
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu
OpenStack, which is subscribed to ceph in Ubuntu.
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1917288

Title:
  Missing to package ceph-kvstore-tool, ceph-monstore-tool, ceph-
  osdomap-tool  in bionic-train UCA release

Status in ceph package in Ubuntu:
  New

Bug description:
  ceph-kvstore-tool, ceph-monstore-tool, ceph-osdomap-tool were shipped
  within ceph-test package,but the ceph-test package was dropped by [0]
  in bionic-train UCA release.

  I believe the reason is that most of the binaries (except those 3
  tools) in ceph-test package are meant for just testing and developing,
  they are not needed for production env, so the idea to drop this
  package is good, but those 3 tools were also dropped along with this
  package.

  Those 3 tools are very important to troubleshoot production issues, so
  we need to add them back.

  Since Luminous, upstream realized that it doesn't make sense to put
  them into ceph-test package, so they've moved those 3 tools to
  different packages in PR[1].

  So, to fix this, we should do the same as upstream, which is :

  Move ceph-kvstore-tool  to ceph-base package
  Move ceph-monstore-tool to ceph-mon package
  Move ceph-osdomap-tool  to ceph-osd package

  Worth mentioning that, upstream also added a PR[2] after [1] was
  landed to fix an upgrade failure, it claims that [1] didn't update the
  relationship between those packages accordingly, thus caused the
  upgrade failure

  Note that this only affects Train, Ussuri does contain those 3 tools.

  [0]https://launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/ceph/14.2.1-0ubuntu1
  [1]https://github.com/ceph/ceph/pull/18289
  [2]https://github.com/ceph/ceph/pull/18474

To manage notifications about this bug go to:
https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/ceph/+bug/1917288/+subscriptions