Please, review this Bugs Importances draft

[Elfy]

On 12/10/14 15:53, C de-Avillez wrote:
> [snip]
>
> YES, it is misrouted: BugSquad is responsible for keeping the triage
> pages. By not addressing the BugSquad, you may be missing some
> interested people.
Surely people should join mailing lists that are of interest to them ;)

Down that road - everyone is in one mailing list ...
>
> NO, it is OK(ish): we discussed, some time ago, joining BugSquad and
> Quality. At the time we thought of keeping the mailing lists and IRC
> channels separate. I have been, lately, wondering if we should
> consider a more radical approach.
I'm glad that the Bugsquad and Quality lists and IRC channel are kept 
seperate - while they might both be looking toward the same goal that 
doesn't necessarily equate to needing to be in the same place.

>
> [ given that I am subscribed to both the busquad and quality ML, I do
> not have loss of information; but I cannot state how many are in one
> and not in the other.]

I wasn't subscribed to both - then when there was a move to join I 
subscribed to the bugsquad list too - I've not seen anything on that 
list that actually affects me nor what I need to know, I've now 
unsubscribed from the bugsquad list.

I would much rather that bugsquad conversation be kept to that list. 
This thread being a prime example ;)

I wouldn't post to the bugsquad list about issues pertaining to alpha, 
beta or rc images nor would I expect people on the bugsquad list to 
assume that would be place to find or discuss those issues

>
> Reasoning: I personally have always seen triage as one aspect of
> quality. This view, to be completely honest, is NOT shared between me
> and the luminaries of QA (and the discussion of why is too long) but I
> do not mind: I still think that they are inter-related.
>
> Right now, the Yes/No ratio (to Alberto's question) is at around 60/40.
I'd disagree at the moment. Editing a bugsquad wiki page would surely be 
the province of the bugsquad.
> [snip]
>


-- 
Ubuntu Forum Council Member
Xubuntu QA Lead