[Bug 1547640] Re: proxy tries ipv6 and gets 503 when no ipv6 routes

[Andreas Hasenack]

I tried downgrading libc6 and restarting squid (heck, even rebooting the
container), but it still happened. Scott IIRC also tried that.

Still, it's a heck of a coincidence.

Squid in debug mode shows it's getting 10 IPv4 and 10 IPv6 addresses back for the archive, and trying each one in turn. But once it crosses over to the ipv4 ones the log gets a bit confusing for me:
2016/02/20 22:18:32.559| ipcache.cc(497) ipcacheParse: ipcacheParse: 20 answers for 'security.ubuntu.com'
2016/02/20 22:18:32.559| ipcache.cc(566) ipcacheParse: ipcacheParse: security.ubuntu.com #0 [2001:67c:1360:8001::17]
2016/02/20 22:18:32.559| ipcache.cc(566) ipcacheParse: ipcacheParse: security.ubuntu.com #1 [2001:67c:1562::15]
2016/02/20 22:18:32.559| ipcache.cc(566) ipcacheParse: ipcacheParse: security.ubuntu.com #2 [2001:67c:1360:8c01::19]
2016/02/20 22:18:32.559| ipcache.cc(566) ipcacheParse: ipcacheParse: security.ubuntu.com #3 [2001:67c:1360:8c01::18]
2016/02/20 22:18:32.559| ipcache.cc(566) ipcacheParse: ipcacheParse: security.ubuntu.com #4 [2001:67c:1562::14]
2016/02/20 22:18:32.559| ipcache.cc(566) ipcacheParse: ipcacheParse: security.ubuntu.com #5 [2001:67c:1562::17]
2016/02/20 22:18:32.559| ipcache.cc(566) ipcacheParse: ipcacheParse: security.ubuntu.com #6 [2001:67c:1560:8001::13]
2016/02/20 22:18:32.559| ipcache.cc(566) ipcacheParse: ipcacheParse: security.ubuntu.com #7 [2001:67c:1562::13]
2016/02/20 22:18:32.559| ipcache.cc(566) ipcacheParse: ipcacheParse: security.ubuntu.com #8 [2001:67c:1562::16]
2016/02/20 22:18:32.559| ipcache.cc(566) ipcacheParse: ipcacheParse: security.ubuntu.com #9 [2001:67c:1560:8001::11]
2016/02/20 22:18:32.559| ipcache.cc(555) ipcacheParse: ipcacheParse: security.ubuntu.com #10 91.189.91.13
2016/02/20 22:18:32.559| ipcache.cc(555) ipcacheParse: ipcacheParse: security.ubuntu.com #11 91.189.88.153
2016/02/20 22:18:32.559| ipcache.cc(555) ipcacheParse: ipcacheParse: security.ubuntu.com #12 91.189.91.15
2016/02/20 22:18:32.559| ipcache.cc(555) ipcacheParse: ipcacheParse: security.ubuntu.com #13 91.189.91.23
2016/02/20 22:18:32.559| ipcache.cc(555) ipcacheParse: ipcacheParse: security.ubuntu.com #14 91.189.88.152
2016/02/20 22:18:32.559| ipcache.cc(555) ipcacheParse: ipcacheParse: security.ubuntu.com #15 91.189.88.149
2016/02/20 22:18:32.559| ipcache.cc(555) ipcacheParse: ipcacheParse: security.ubuntu.com #16 91.189.92.201
2016/02/20 22:18:32.559| ipcache.cc(555) ipcacheParse: ipcacheParse: security.ubuntu.com #17 91.189.91.24
2016/02/20 22:18:32.559| ipcache.cc(555) ipcacheParse: ipcacheParse: security.ubuntu.com #18 91.189.92.200
2016/02/20 22:18:32.559| ipcache.cc(555) ipcacheParse: ipcacheParse: security.ubuntu.com #19 91.189.91.14

Marks :17 as bad:
2016/02/20 22:18:32.560| ipcache.cc(1075) ipcacheMarkBadAddr: ipcacheMarkBadAddr: security.ubuntu.com [2001:67c:1360:8001::17]:80

Decides to check :15
2016/02/20 22:18:32.560| ipcache.cc(1039) ipcacheCycleAddr: ipcacheCycleAddr: security.ubuntu.com now at [2001:67c:1562::15] (2 of 20)
2016/02/20 22:18:32.560| AsyncCall.cc(85) ScheduleCall: ConnOpener.cc(132) will call fwdConnectDoneWrapper(local=[::] remote=[2001:67c:1360:8001::17]:80 flags=1, errno=101, flag=-8, data=0x555c4de451b8) [call23]
(...)

last ipv6 one, starting ipv4:
2016/02/20 22:18:32.568| ipcache.cc(1075) ipcacheMarkBadAddr: ipcacheMarkBadAddr: security.ubuntu.com [2001:67c:1560:8001::11]:80
2016/02/20 22:18:32.568| ipcache.cc(1039) ipcacheCycleAddr: ipcacheCycleAddr: security.ubuntu.com now at 91.189.91.13 (11 of 20)
2016/02/20 22:18:32.568| AsyncCall.cc(85) ScheduleCall: ConnOpener.cc(132) will call fwdConnectDoneWrapper(local=[::] remote=[2001:67c:1560:8001::11]:80 flags=1, errno=101, flag=-8, data=0x555c4de451b8) [call68]
(...)

I don't see it trying the ipv4 address, just considering it, but no connection attempt:
2016/02/20 22:18:32.577| ConnOpener.cc(346) connect: local=[::] remote=[2001:67c:1562::15]:80 flags=1: * - ERR tried too many times already.
2016/02/20 22:18:32.577| ipcache.cc(1039) ipcacheCycleAddr: ipcacheCycleAddr: security.ubuntu.com now at 91.189.91.15 (13 of 20)
2016/02/20 22:18:32.577| AsyncCall.cc(85) ScheduleCall: ConnOpener.cc(132) will call fwdConnectDoneWrapper(local=[::] remote=[2001:67c:1562::15]:80 flags=1, errno=101, flag=-8, data=0x555c4de451b8) [call83]

That's how far I got.

-- 
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu
Server Team, which is subscribed to squid3 in Ubuntu.
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1547640

Title:
  proxy tries ipv6 and gets 503 when no ipv6 routes

To manage notifications about this bug go to:
https://bugs.launchpad.net/maas/+bug/1547640/+subscriptions