External HDD is corrupted

[Agent M]

The Seagate Drive is new, and so hasn't had chance to be knocked
around...yet, there is also no data on it, so data loss through extended
tests are not a concern at the moment, if they were I would of focused
on data recovery first.

As mentioned I also ran the seatools - long test in addition to the
chkdsk, and that also passed. I agree chkdsk isn't the best disk
checking program out there and so normally use something else in
addition or instead of chkdsk

The gnome Disk Utility says SMART is unavailable ( possibly because its
connected via USB??? ), and so can't read the values that your referring
to. I also tried GSmartControl, that was also unable to get the SMART
info.

This may be a silly question, but could it be possible for the type of
enclosures that I have to be the source of such issues? maybe not 100%
compatible with linux?? I know this may be a stretch, but at this point
am grasping at straws.


-----Original Message-----
From: compdoc <compdoc at hotrodpc.com>
Reply-to: compdoc at hotrodpc.com, "Ubuntu user technical support, not for
general discussions" <ubuntu-users at lists.ubuntu.com>
To: 'Ubuntu user technical support, not for general discussions'
<ubuntu-users at lists.ubuntu.com>
Subject: RE: External HDD is corrupted
Date: Thu, 27 Mar 2014 08:17:30 -0600


> I also ran a full chkdsk scan to check for bad sectors, and it found no
problems.

Chkdsk is getting to be pretty old and although MS has updated it, chkdsk
has very limited use for detecting bad sectors. Mainly because modern drives
'reallocate' bad sectors as they occur, so the OS rarely sees the bad
sectors. 

Unfortunately, reallocation doesn't guarantee your data is not damaged in
the process. Also, when you notice a drive is having problems, I think it's
a bad idea to run extended tests on it, because you're more likely to
further risk your data by working the drive hard.

A hard drives records everything that happens in its lifetime in SMART, so
the best way to know if your drive is failing is to read the SMART info on
the drive. 

You can use the gnome Disk Utility to read SMART, and you want to pay
attention to these values:

Reallocated sector count
Current pending sector count
Reported Uncorrectable Errors (I think this one is more rare)
Temperature

And since the drive is in an external enclosure and subject to getting
knocked around, look at:

GSense Error rate

The actual, important numbers for these events is in the last column, often
named 'Raw'. If you have anything other than all zeros in this column for
the mentioned attributes, the drive is experiencing hardware failures.




-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <https://lists.ubuntu.com/archives/ubuntu-users/attachments/20140327/ca2911ec/attachment.html>